Not all shelter animals come with baggage, but they do come with stories, personalities, and a whole lot of love to give. Somewhere along the way, a few pesky myths have clung to the idea of shelter pets like fur on black pants: that they’re “damaged,” untrainable, or second-best. We’re here to set the record straight. At the Fredericksburg SPCA, we know that shelter animals aren’t broken—they’ve just been waiting for someone to see their potential. Let’s bust some myths and show why adoption might just be the best decision you never knew you needed.
Common Myths About Shelter Pets (and Why They’re Rubbish)
Myth 1: Shelter pets are “damaged goods.”
Reality: Most animals end up in shelters due to human circumstances like moving, allergies, financial hardship—not because there’s anything wrong with them. They’re just looking for a fresh start.
Myth 2: You don’t know what you’re getting.
Reality: At the Fredericksburg SPCA, our team works to learn each pet’s personality and quirks. We’re basically the dating profile writers for dogs and cats, and we’ll match you with your soulmate, no swiping required- unless belly rubs count as swipes.
Myth 3: Shelter animals are all old.
Reality: We’ve got pets of every age, from wide-eyed kittens and puppies to wise, nap-loving seniors. There’s a perfect age range for everyone, including those who prefer less zoom and more snooze.
Myth 4: It’s too hard to train a shelter pet.
Reality: Shelter pets are incredibly resilient and eager to learn. Many are already house-trained, and all they need is a little patience, consistency, and someone who believes in them. Bonus: Our PetCademy training support is here to help.
Myth 5: They won’t bond with you.
Reality: Shelter pets absolutely bond, sometimes even more deeply because they know what it means to be chosen. Give it a little time and a lot of love, and you’ll have a best friend for life.
Myth 6: Shelter pets all have behavioral issues.
Reality: Most shelter animals are just adjusting to new environments and frankly, who doesn’t act a little weird when their whole life gets turned upside down? A stable home and a little TLC work wonders.
Myth 7: It’s easier to just buy from a breeder.
Reality: Reputable, ethical breeders are often overlooked due to higher costs, waitlists, and strict contracts. However, choosing not to do proper research often leads buyers to unknowingly support puppy mills with good marketing or irresponsible backyard breeders. Adopting is faster, more affordable, and saves lives. Plus, your new best friend comes pre-equipped with gratitude and a killer backstory.
Myth 8: You can’t find good family pets in a shelter.
Reality: Many shelter pets came from families and are already kid-tested and nap-approved. We work hard to match pets with the right households whether that’s toddlers, teens, or a quiet book club for two.
Myth 9: You’ll feel bad walking through the shelter.
Reality: We get it—it can tug at your heartstrings. But shelter pets aren’t sitting around in despair. They’re playing, snuggling, scheming for treats, and waiting (somewhat impatiently) for their next adventure. You might just be the plot twist they’ve been hoping for. Pro Tip: If you want to hang with one of our dogs outside of the shelter, check out our Adventure Tails program and take a pupper for a day of fun and sunshine!
Myth 10: Shelter pets are sick or unhealthy.
Reality: Every animal at the Fredericksburg SPCA receives medical care, vaccinations, spay/neuter surgery, and lots of TLC before they’re available for adoption. Those who have medical conditions are treated while they are with us, and you’ll get plenty of education on how to continue their care at home. You’re not adopting a mystery illness; you’re adopting a well-loved, well-checked fluffball.
